Don't Get a Nook

by Sean Smith
(LA)

I want to warn people out there who are thinking about buying a nook from Barnes and Noble. First off, their customer service is abysmal. I can't tell you much time I wasted on the phone with customer service trying to get that stupid nook to work properly. The reps don't know squat about the actual functionality of the nook. And the worst part is, I had a defective one and they still made me pay a 10% restocking fee to return it. Bastards.

After owning a Sony 505 since it first came out I thought it would be nice to upgrade to a new reader with wireless. I didn't want a Kindle because I already have a bunch of e-books in epub and pdf format that would be completely useless on the Kindle, and I didn't want Sony's new touchscreen model because of the glare. I wanted a 6" reader so I decided on the Barnes and Noble nook.

Big mistake.

I thought it would be an upgrade from the 505 since it's two years newer, but it is more like a downgrade.

The speed at which it turns pages is flat out ridiculously slow, even with the latest firmware update. How can a new reader be this slow, I ask. Some books are better than others but many of the ones I have from places like Gutenberg take like 3 seconds to turn a page. And I'm not exaggerating. Perhaps if you only want to buy e-books from Barnes and Noble it's fine, but most of their e-books are in their own format when they are supposed to be epub.

The nook's pdf handling is a joke, even re-flow is useless because it sends lines all over the place, and this must be the only reader on the planet that doesn't have landscape mode. So all my pdf e-books were useless.

The 3G was broken on my nook. It worked the first day and then never worked again. Only Wi-Fi worked. After several frustrating calls to customer service, and after basically getting blown off by them, I took the nook back to the store that I bought it from and attempted to return it.

They wanted me to exchange it for another one but I declined because I decided I wanted a brand that actually worked without the hassle of rude and unhelpful customer service (after 1 hour on hold on the phone I want nothing to do with you, B&N).

I told the rep that I wanted my money back because I was not pleased with many of the nooks capabilities and their misrepresentation of facts, saying it supports pdf is a stretch of the truth and also saying they have the largest library of e-books is a flat out lie because most are from Google and are better formatted from anywhere else.

But I still can't believe the guy insisted on charging me about $26 in re-stocking fees on a defective unit. He said that they have to charge that no matter what if it has been opened.

F*** that. I'll never shop at Barnes and Noble again as long as I live.

If you are considering buying a nook, take it from someone who has already been there and get something else. There are many better options out there.

Comments for
Don't Get a Nook

Average Rating starstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Mar 16, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
not a problem on this end
by: Anonymous

I imagine that B&N might have customer service issues with a hardware product and need to deal with is asap, but my nook is fantastic and i would never buy a sony product. Do they even have "customer service' ? whats the number to talk to a person ? Sony's claim to fame is "quality and brand" which is crap.. their ereader probably has a virus on it anyways.

I bought a nook for epub and pdf capability and it's just fine - absolutely no problems. 3G and wifi works and the page turn is also just fine.

Apr 07, 2010
Rating
starstarstar
Things have improved some
by: Doug

B&N has since made a huge improvement in their Customer Service department, and generally there's no wait and the person you connect to is knowledgeable.

As of about today (April 7, 2010), the 10% restocking fee is no longer in effect. You can now return your nook within 14 days for a full refund.

Page turning speed hasn't been an issue for me. There are reported glitches with certain improperly-formatted e-books. Updated firmware is expected later this month, and we can hope that the new firmware is more robust when fed garbage.

The PDF support is just as described in the formal review on this site: "Basic text-based PDF ebooks don't even fair too well." Using any e-reader for general PDFs will lead to sorrow; it's nothing specific with the nook. PDF is a page-layout format and most PDFs are laid out for letter/A4 pages. Trying to fit them on the 6" e-Ink screen is a problem. BeBook provides some e-books in PDF that were specifically formatted for the 6" screen, and they seem to work fine.

B&N's e-books aren't "supposed to be epub", and they haven't claimed that. B&N is slowly changing over from its eReader format to EPUB with eReader DRM. The nook is the only e-reader device that currently can handle either of those formats, so the change isn't a big deal for outsiders. The nook does have somewhat different behavior for EPUBs than for eReader PDBs; for example, EPUB page numbering is constant while eReader page numbers change with the font choice.

My nook works just fine for eReader and EPUB e-books. Is it perfect? No; the review on this site which pretty much says it like it is.

Aug 03, 2010
Rating
star
I agree!
by: Anonymous

After only two months of use, my Nook decided to stop working altogether. I could kick myself for not ordering a Kindle, however lesson has been learned. I'm not going to waste my time in contacting customer service as it appears B & N customer service is inferior, so let's not waste our time. Amazon.com here I come!

Aug 24, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
I would totally agree with you, but its not opposite day
by: Anonymous

I dont care what people say because I have had only one problem with the nook and its minor. It just does not change the page number until i have tured the page multiple times.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How?
Simply click here to return to eBook Reader Reviews and Articles